Magyar’s HOT Break with Orbán’s Shield for Israel

  • Hungarian Prime Minister Péter Magyar lifted Budapest’s veto on European Union sanctions against Israeli settlers and reversed Viktor Orbán’s withdrawal from the International Criminal Court.
  • Magyar kept close bilateral ties, hosting Israeli President Isaac Herzog in October 2026 ahead of the 70th anniversary of the 1956 uprising. 
  • Neither Fidesz nor Netanyahu could reverse the shift, and Magyar’s wider reset with Brussels is on track to unlock frozen EU funds.
Péter Magyar - Prime Minister of Hungary Attribution: © European Union, 1998 – 2026
Péter Magyar – Prime Minister of Hungary
Attribution: © European Union, 1998 – 2026

Why is Péter Magyar HOT?

Answer: Magyar departed from Orbán’s behaviour in European institutions and at the International Criminal Court within weeks of taking power, while keeping a strong relationship with Israel.

On 20 October 2026, Hungarian Prime Minister Péter Magyar welcomed Israeli President Isaac Herzog to Parliament. Three days later, Budapest celebrated the 70th anniversary of the 1956 uprising without Benjamin Netanyahu in attendance, although the latter’s office said in April that Magyar had invited him.

The new prime minister took office on 9 May 2026 after the Respect and Freedom Party (Tisza) halted sixteen years of rule by Viktor Orbán’s Fidesz. Under Orbán, Hungary was widely considered Israel’s “most reliable shield in the European Union”.

For example, it delayed sanctions on West Bank settlers, blocked EU statements on behalf of the 27 members, and began withdrawing from the International Criminal Court after the institution issued an arrest warrant for Netanyahu. Netanyahu called Orbán a “true friend of Israel”.

Two days after the change of government, Hungary dropped its veto, and the EU adopted its first sanctions on violent settlers in over a year. Magyar further delivered on his April pledge that, in the “best interest of the international community”, Hungary should rejoin the ICC.

On 27 May 2026, a few days before the exit was due to conclude, the Hungarian Parliament revoked the ICC withdrawal by 133 votes against 37, with Magyar arguing that anyone wanted by the court “must be taken into custody”.

At the same time, the prime minister promised a “balanced” foreign policy with EU positions on Israel to be decided case by case. He has continued engaging Israel as a close partner through its institutional channels, keeping what he calls a “special relationship” and accepting Herzog’s invitation to visit the country. As Hungary remains a friend without assuming the shield’s functions, Magyar fulfilled his campaign promises, leaving him HOT.

What is changing Péter Magyar’s heat level?

Answer: Tisza’s policy has been challenged by Fidesz and Netanyahu. However, favourable public opinion within Hungary gives Magyar a mandate to carry out these reforms. 

Despite Fidesz voting against the ICC reversal in line with its previous decision, its parliamentarians are no longer an obstacle following Tisza’s landslide victory. The reversal was signed by then President Tamás Sulyok (appointed by Fidesz) and became effective on 29 May.  

However, although Fidesz can still advance the interests of Likud via “Patriots for Europe”, its group in the European Parliament, it can no longer wield a government veto. 

Netanyahu himself acted as an outside pressure, with his office’s announcement of the April invitation which EUobserver described as a deliberate test of the prime minister’s ICC campaign pledge, and Magyar answered that the invitation stood, alongside the arrest obligation. 

A former Israeli ambassador said that Israel was “not losing a friend but a consistent protector inside the EU system”. The personal ideological closeness of Orbán’s tenure is no more, and Netanyahu’s own position is in doubt, as after the 27 October Israeli election, Herzog tasked Gadi Eisenkot from the opposition with forming a government.

Within Hungary, public opinion lets Magyar distance himself from Netanyahu while keeping the state-to-state tie intact: in a Pew Research Centre survey conducted in spring 2026, 54% of Hungarians viewed Israel unfavourably, and  65% distrusted Netanyahu, up from 57% in 2025.

As of November 2026, Tisza is leading Fidesz by 55% to 16%, suggesting that the policy change does not cost Magyar any opinion points, keeping him HOT.

What is driving Péter Magyar?

Answer: Magyar aims to be perceived as the leader who restored the rule of law as well as Hungary’s place in Europe, which he can do through the government’s stance on Israel.

As a former Fidesz insider, Magyar was able to gain support in Hungary by speaking out against corruption within the system. Thus, his return to the ICC and abandonment of the veto constitute symbolic moves of departure from the former government.

As prime minister-elect, Magyar went to the Holocaust Memorial Centre on 16 April, an image that Hungarian Jews received positively after Orbán’s departure. He also benefits from high popularity among his compatriots, scoring  63% in a CEU Democracy Institute popularity poll this summer against 25% for Orbán.

In terms of governance priorities, relationships with Brussels are paramount. In May 2026, Magyar reached an agreement with Commission President Ursula von der Leyen to release the previously frozen €16.4 billion over rule-of-law concerns. Ending Orbán’s vetoes on Israel also helped restore international trust.

However, this relationship with Brussels may slightly restrict Magyar’s foreign policy. Due to the financial incentives at stake, Budapest has little interest in going against the Commission. The pragmatic links with the Israeli Government remain active, with the new Hungarian President, András Baka, describing relations as being “cordial and stable” and mentioning no “outstanding bilateral issues”. 

What does this mean for you?

Answer: Magyar’s Hungary will no longer act as Israel’s veto in the EU, but Europe’s policy towards Israel will change only as fast as the other member states allow.

In the short term, a €10 billion payment from the Recovery and Resilience Facility, part of €16.4 billion, must be made before the end of 2026. While the Commission indicates that it “has not identified major obstacles”, it is currently performing final checks. A delay would deny Magyar a key domestic win.

In Israel, Eisenkot has until early December (although potentially extended) to form a government. Thus, the relations for the year to come and Magyar’s planned visit will hinge on the composition of the future cabinet.

In the longer term, Hungary’s policy change does not represent a fundamental shift in EU policy. Other countries are reluctant to take steps such as curbing trade ties. As Ian Bond of the Centre for European Reform pointed out after Magyar’s election, Israel “still has other countries on its side”. 

What it lost is a government constantly willing to block European majority decisions and defy the International Criminal Court. Under Magyar, Hungary will offer Israel camaraderie instead of systematic protection.

Raphaël Maurer

Research & Analysis Intern